"To the Officers and Members of Shelbina Lodge, No. 142, I.O.O.F., The subscriber, having received the ___(1)__ Degree, and the constitutional period having elapsed since receiving said Degree, now desires to advance in the Order by receiving the Degree of ___(2)___."
| Name | Date | Degree (1) | Degree (2) |
| ADAMS, C. E. | 20 Mar 1911 | Initiation | Friendship |
| ADAMS, C. E. | 3 Apr 1911 | First | Brotherly Love |
| ADAMS, C. E. | 3 Apr1911 | Second | Truth |
| ANDERSON, Don L. | 23 Jan 1911 | Initiation | Friendship |
| ANDERSON, Don L. | 6 Feb 1911 | First | Brotherly Love |
| ANDERSON, Don L. | 20 Feb 1911 | Second | Truth |
| BAKER, John L. | 18 Apr 1910 | Initiation | Friendship |
| BAKER, John L. | 23 May 1910 | First | Brotherly Love |
| BAKER, John L. | 6 Jun 1910 | Second | Truth |
| BOYD, W. Jr. | 8 Jan 1912 | Initiation | Friendship |
| BOYD, W. Jr. | 22 Jan 1912 | First | Brotherly Love |
| BOYD, W. Jr. | 5 Feb 1912 | Second | Truth |
| BUSH, Samuel H. | 6 Mar 1911 | Initiation | Friendship |
| BUSH, Samuel H. | 27 Mar 1911 | First | Brotherly Love |
| BUSH, Samuel H. | 17 Apr 1911 | Second | Truth |
| CADWELL, Frank M. | 8 Jan 1912 | Initiation | Friendship |
| CADWELL, Frank M. | 22 Jan 1912 | First | Brotherly Love |
| CADWELL, Frank M. | 5 Feb 1912 | Second | Truth |
| CALDWELL, J. R. | 9 May 1910 | Initiation | Friendship |
| CALDWELL, J. R. | 23 May 1910 | First | Brotherly Love |
| CALDWELL, J. R. | 1 Aug 1910 | Second | Truth |
| CALDWELL, S. T. | 9 May 1910 | Initiation | Friendship |
| CALDWELL, S. T. | 23 May 1910 | First | Brotherly Love |
| CALDWELL, S. T. | 6 Jun 1910 | Second | Truth |
| CLAUSE, C. W. | 29 Jan 1912 | Initiation | Friendship |
| CLAUSE, C. W. | 12 Feb 1912 | First | Brotherly Love |
| CLAUSE, C. W. | 4 Mar 1912 | Second | Truth |
| CONNAWAY, John T. | 14 Dec 1908 | Initiation | Friendship |
| CONNAWAY, John T. | 28 Dec 1908 | First | Brotherly Love |
| CONNAWAY, John T. | 18 Jan 1909 | Second | Truth |
| DEAR, H. T. | 13 Jan 1908 | Initiation | Friendship |
| DEAR, H. T. | 20 Jan 1908 | First | Brotherly Love |
| DEAR, H. T. | 3 Feb 1908 | Second | Truth |
| DOCTOR, Roy | 21 Feb 1910 | Initiation | Friendship |
| DOCTOR, Roy | 7 Mar 1910 | First | Brotherly Love |
| DOCTOR, Roy | 21 Mar 1910 | Second | Truth |
| DRYE, Dave | 10 Jan 1910 | Initiation | Friendship |
| DRYE, Dave | 17 Jan 1910 | First | Brotherly Love |
| DRYE, Dave | 31 Jan 1910 | Second | Truth |
| DURHAM, V. E. | 23 Jan 1911 | Initiation | Friendship |
| DURHAM, V. E. | 20 Feb 1911 | Second | Truth |
| ERTEL, W. N. | 9 Oct 1911 | Initiation | Friendship |
| GOGAN, Thomas | 28 Mar 1910 | Initiation | Friendship |
| GREENING, James T. | 10 Jan 1910 | Initiation | Friendship |
| GREENING, James T. | 17 Jan 1910 | First | Brotherly Love |
| GREENING, James T. | 31 Jan 1910 | Second | Truth |
| HARDING, C. E. | 20 Mar 1911 | Initiation | Friendship |
| HARDING, C. E. | Apr 1911 | First | Brotherly Love |
| HARDING, C. E. | 17 Apr 1911 | Second | Truth |
| HARLAND, E. W. | 21 Feb 1910 | Initiation | Friendship |
| HARLAND, E. W. | 7 Mar 1910 | First | Brotherly Love |
| HARLAND, E. W. | 28 Mar 1910 | Second | Truth |
| HARRISON, R. Lee | 8 Jan 1912 | Initiation | Friendship |
| HARRISON, R. Lee | 22 Jan 1912 | First | Brotherly Love |
| HARRISON, R. Lee | 5 Feb 1912 | Second | Truth |
| HARRISON, Ray R. | 22 Jan 1912 | First | Brotherly Love |
| HARRISON, Ray R. | 5 Feb 1912 | Second | Truth |
| HAWKINS, A. B. | 13 Jan 1908 | Initiation | Friendship |
| HAWKINS, A. B. | 20 Jan 1908 | First | Brotherly Love |
| HAWKINS, A. B. | 3 Feb 1908 | Second | Truth |
| HAWKINS, T. N. | 13 Jan 1908 | Initiation | Friendship |
| HAWKINS, T. N. | 20 Jan 1908 | First | Brotherly Love |
| HAWKINS, T. N. | 3 Feb 1908 | Second | Truth |
| HEATHMAN, William | 22 Feb 1910 | Initiation | Friendship |
| HEATHMAN, William | 7 Mar 1910 | First | Brotherly Love |
| HEATHMAN, William | 21 Mar 1910 | Second | Truth |
| HENNINGER, H. F. | 11 May 1908 | Initiation | Friendship |
| HENNINGER, H. F. | 25 May 1908 | First | Brotherly Love |
| HENNINGER, H. F. | 8 Jun 1908 | Second | Truth |
| HOWELL, Floyd R. | 8 Jan 1912 | Initiation | Friendship |
| HOWELL, Floyd R. | 5 Feb 1912 | Second | Truth |
| KERN, John L. | 20 Mar 1911 | Initiation | Friendship |
| KERN, John L. | 17 Apr 1911 | Second | Truth |
| LANCASTER, W. C. "Callie" | 22 Nov 1909 | Initiation | Friendship |
| LANCASTER, W. C. "Callie" | 17 Jan 1910 | First | Brotherly Love |
| LANCASTER, W. C. "Callie" | 31 Jan 1910 | Second | Truth |
| LEATON, J. W. F. | 26 Feb 1912 | Initiation | Friendship |
| LEATON, J. W. F. | 11 Mar 1912 | First | Brotherly Love |
| LEATON, J. W. F. | 25 Mar 1912 | Second | Truth |
| LYDICK, George | 18 Jan 1908 | Initiation | Friendship |
| LYDICK, George | 20 Jan 1908 | First | Brotherly Love |
| LYDICK, George | 3 Feb 1908 | Second | Truth |
| MARTIN, W. L. | 20 Mar 1911 | Initiation | Friendship |
| MARTIN, W. L. | 3 Apr 1911 | First | Brotherly Love |
| MARTIN, W. L. | 17 Apr 1911 | Second | Truth |
| MAYFIELD, G. E. | 21 Feb 1910 | Initiation | Friendship |
| MAYFIELD, G. E. | 7 Mar 1910 | First | Brotherly Love |
| MAYFIELD, G. E. | 28 Mar 1910 | Second | Truth |
| McINTOSH, C. W. | Initiation | Friendship | |
| McINTOSH, C. W. | 20 Jan 1908 | First | Brotherly Love |
| McINTOSH, C. W. | 3 Feb 1908 | Second | Truth |
| MILLION, Earle K. | 12 Jun 1911 | Initiation | Friendship |
| MILLION, Earle K. | 10 Jul 1911 | First | Brotherly Love |
| NIES, Walter V. | 8 Jan 1912 | Initiation | Friendship |
| NIES, Walter V. | 22 Jan 1912 | First | Brotherly Love |
| NIES, Walter V. | 5 Feb 1912 | Second | Truth |
| NIES, Theron G. | 8 Jan 1912 | Initiation | Friendship |
| NIES, Theron G. | 22 Jan 1912 | First | Brotherly Love |
| NIES, Theron G. | 5 Feb 1912 | Second | Truth |
| SEARS, J. M. | 30 Mar 1908 | Initiation | Friendship |
| SEARS, J. M. | 13 Apr 1908 | First | Brotherly Love |
| SEARS, J. M. | 27 Apr 1908 | Second | Truth |
| SMOCK, Stanley C. | 8 Jan 1912 | Initiation | Friendship |
| SMOCK, Stanley C. | 22 Jan 1912 | First | Brotherly Love |
| SMOCK, Stanley C. | 4 Mar 1912 | Second | Truth |
| SNIDER, C. E. | 12 Jun 1911 | Initiation | Friendship |
| SNIDER, C. E. | 10 Jul 1911 | First | Brotherly Love |
| SNYDER, Norval | 18 Jan 1908 | Initiation | Friendshp |
| SNYDER, Norval | 20 Jan 1908 | First | Brotherly Love |
| SNYDER, Norval | 3 Feb 1908 | Second | Truth |
| SWINNEY, E. D. Jr. | 10 Jan 1910 | Initiation | Friendship |
| SWINNEY, E. D. Jr. | 17 Jan 1910 | First | Brotherly Love |
| SWINNEY, E. D. Jr. | 31 Jan 1910 | Second | Truth |
| TAYLOR, William | 10 Jan 1910 | Initiation | Friendship |
| TAYLOR, William | 17 Jan 1910 | First | Brotherly Love |
| TAYLOR, William | 31 Jan 1910 | Second | Truth |
| TURNER, Frank R. | 16 Sep 1912 | Initiation | Friendship |
| TURNER, Frank R. | 30 Sep 1912 | First | Brotherly Love |
| TURNER, Frank R. | 7 Oct 1912 | Second | Truth |
| WHITE, Thomas B. | 29 Jan 1912 | Initiation | Friendship |
| WHITE, Thomas B. | 12 Feb 1912 | First | Brotherly Love |
| WHITE, Thomas B. | 4 Mar 1912 | Second | Truth |
| WHITELOCK, Rollin L. | 20 Jun 1910 | Initiation | Friendship |
| WHITELOCK, Rollin L. | 27 Jun 1910 | First | Brotherly Love |
| WHITELOCK, Rollin L. | 18 Jul 1910 | Second | Truth |
| WILSON, James B. | 10 Jan 1910 | Initiation | Friendship |
| WILSON, James B. | 17 Jan 1910 | First | Brotherly Love |
| WILSON, James B. | 31 Jan 1910 | Second | Truth |
| WILT, Charles N. | 21 Dec 1908 | Initiation | Friendship |
| WILT, Charles N. | 1 Mar 1909 | First | Brotherly Love |
| WILT, Charles N. | 17 Apr 1911 | Second | Truth |
| WINGATE, J. N. | 23 Jan 1911 | Initiation | Friendship |
| WINGATE, J. N. | 10 Apr 1911 | First | Brotherly Love |
| WINGATE, J. N. | Jun 1911 | Second | Truth |